Schmidt temple university ian wilkinson university of new south wales, new south wales, australia the tactics used by people at work to influence their superiors, coworkers, and subordinates were investigated in two studies. Table 1 from consequences of influence tactics used with. An overview of upward influence tactics research india. Explorations in getting ones way, journal of applied psychology, vol.
The globalization of work within organizations has generated a greater need for all type of workers to exert interpersonal influence through technologymediated communication tools. Shotgun managers, tacticians, and bystanders d kipnis, sm schmidt, c swaffinsmith, i wilkinson organizational dynamics 12 3, 5867, 1984. This paper reports an empirical investigation of individual preferences in the use of managerial influence tactics by hong kong chinese and americans. Pdf in study 1, 165 lowerlevel managers wrote essays describing an incident in which they influenced either their bosses, coworkers, or. To date, the major scholarly effort has been dedicated to the exploration of intraorganizational politics based on employees perceptions.
Explorations in getting one s way journal of appl,ied psychology, 65 4 1980, pp. Impact of managerial influence tactics on job creativity and. However, one of the important aspects of this phenomenon is the way in which it is viewed by the external organizational environmentby customers, clients, and as far as governmental agencies are. Intraorganizational influence behavior can be divided. Combining established theories on power, influence tactics, and resistance, we developed the ranked levels of influence model. Abaixo relacionamos as referencias bibliograficas consultadas em sua elaboracao. The 1993 special research forum on configurations is dedicated to the proposition that configurational theory and research can significantly advance understanding of people, groups, and organizations.
The study examined both the tactics adopted by these project managers to influence people, and their level of decision authority. Since successful leadership development programs teach students effective skills to communicate ideas, understand others opinions, and influence decisions, how can we make classrooms. Power is widely acknowledged to affect negotiator performance. In study 1, 165 lowerlevel managers wrote essays describing an incident in which they influenced either their bosses, coworkers, or subordinates. Salancik, jeffrey pfeffer a behavioral interpretation of power kenneth r. The most effective tactics were rational persuasion, inspirational appeal, and. The multisource feedback was based on ratings of a managers influence behavior by subordinates, peers, and bosses. Outras referencias vem sendo adicionadas posteriormente, a medida. Wilkinson, wilkinson construction and validation of an instrument for measuring ingratiatory behaviors in organizational settings. Bibliography for the art of influencing university of glasgow. The first dimension distinguishes the types of tactics used to bring about attitude change. Explorations in getting ones way,reprinted from vol. Academy of management, publishers ofay of management recadem view, foa social in. The tactics used by people at work to influence their superiors, coworkers, and subordinates were investigated in two studies.
Mar 17, 2006 intraorganizational influence tactics. A career in organized anarchy proceedings of the 2018 acm. An examination of omission as a managerial reinforcement strategy, proceedings of. Pdf consequences of influence tactics used with subordinates. Configurational approaches to organizational analysis. The purpose of the study was to compare manageremployee influencing dynamics within the framework of transformational and transactional leadership theory. Explorations in getting one s way david kipnis and stuart m. Schmidt, stuart m wilkinson, ian journal of applied psychology. Managers in the feedback workshop increased their use of some core influence tactics with subordinates, whereas there was no change in behavior for the control group or for the comparison group. An examination of omission as a managerial reinforcement strategy, proceedings of the southern management. Little is known about the effectiveness of managerial influence tactics on job creativity and performance in the airline industry. Upward and downward influence tactics in managerial networks. A study of strategies preferred by head nurses and infection control practitioners barbara goldrick, rn, phl, cic8 jeanne leclair, mph, mtascpb elaine larson, rn, phl, faan, cic8 washington, d.
Based on previous research, eleven hypotheses and a theoretical model was conducted under the assumption that individual influence tactics affect job creativity, job creativity has a positive influence on job performance, and job creativity mediates both influence. Jan 05, 2007 intraorganizational influence tactics. Thompson, fred luthans power failure in management circuits rosabeth moss kanter intraorganizational influence tactics. This study tested this theory empirically using the thomaskilmann conflict mode instrument to measure the five conflict resolution styles of 201 managers 99 males and 102 females in both situational roles. Mar 17, 2006 this research explores whether individuals have implicit theories of persuasion.
Safety free fulltext leaders influence tactics for. In contrast to positive effects in the organization, influence tactics is also labeled to have negative aspects and outcomes. Presidential race not only transformed how leaders successfully challenge the status quo, but also created innovative teaching opportunities in this new leadership era. Relative status of employees and styles of handling interpersonal conflict. Because women and men managers occupy different roles at work and at home, role theory suggests that they would use different conflict resolution behaviors in each role. Implicit theories of persuasion human communication. For hard influence tactics, high vs low expert power buffered the negative relationship of upward appeal and pressure on itp via management support. It was the purpose of this research to analyze the factorial and construct validity of the profile of organizational influence strategies, form m of kipnis and schmidt, which assesses attempts to influence a manager and also attempts when the manager has resisted doing what the employee wants. This research explores whether individuals have implicit theories of persuasion. These approaches are ranked in success in ascending order based on the study. Schmidt temple university ian wilkinson university of new south wales, new south wales, australia the tactics used by people at work to influence their superiors, coworkers, and. Introduction one of the challenges in teaching leadership knowledge and skills is the limited opportunity to apply theory into practice.
Nine generic influence tactics musings on organizational. In this introductory essay, we define configurational approaches to organizational analysis, trace the history of configurational thinking, distinguish the contingency approach from the. Explorations in getting ones way kipnis, d schmidt, s. Power to influence leadership perceptions and innovatively. Through content analysis, a total of 370 influence tactics in 14 categories were identified. The purpose of this study was to examine influencing strategy preferences among head nurses hns in. Subjects in a crosscultural scenario study were asked to evaluate alternative upward and downward influence tactics in terms of their preferred usage. Power and influence power, politics, and influence p. Relationship of transformational and transactional leadership. This paper contributes to the analysis of interpersonal relations in virtual environments from a specific perspective. As a result, teaching of leadership often emphasizes theories primarily through lectures, personality assessments, and case studies of ceos ferris, 1998.
The first study sought to understand how persuasive strategies are cognitively represented. Busmhr 8601 ben tepper organizational behavior part one. Upward influence tactics in virtual work settings semantic. It then attempted to determine if these two characteristics varied along with the projects organizational structure. Using authentic leader dilemmas to teach microinfluence. Bibliography for amb305 queensland university of technology. Ebscohost serves thousands of libraries with premium essays, articles and other content including intraorganizational influence tactics. Using multidimensional scaling, two dimensions were identified. Strategies and personality types used by primary school. These are memorable tactics to use when in the work field, and importance and value can not be underestimated.
Exploring the impact of gender role selfperception on communication style. Explorations in getting ones way david kipnis and stuart m. Intraorganizational influence tactics exploration in getting ones way. Bringing real life dynamics into the classroom is often time taking and demanding. A growing body of research has pointed out effective leadership as an important influencing factor for safety performance in various highrisk industrial contexts. Nov 30, 2017 the 1993 special research forum on configurations is dedicated to the proposition that configurational theory and research can significantly advance understanding of people, groups, and organizations. Explorations in getting ones way article pdf available in journal of applied psychology 654. Yet few efforts have been made to integrate the most prominent theories of power into a cohesive framework that can account for the results from a broad array of negotiationrelevant research. Leader characteristics, selfconfidence, and methods of upward influence in organizations decision situations. The impact of the administrative hypocrisy on the career path from. Upward influence tactics appears to be a prime component of the organizational politics.
Full text views reflects the number of pdf downloads. Interorganizational influence tactics explorations in getting. They reported having few personal or organizational objec. Schmidt, ian wilkinson power, dependence, and effective management john p. Apr 12, 2010 these approaches are ranked in success in ascending order based on the study. The findings indicate a main effect for culture and for direction of influence attempt. An empirical analysis of linguistic strategies used in superiorsubordinate communication. Recognizing effective means of influence is of value for safety leadership. Gender differences in conflict resolution styles of managers. However, limited systematic knowledge is available about how leaders can effectively persuade rule compliance, and stimulate actions and participation.
Validity assessments of compliance gaining exemplars. Moving toward a global understanding of upward influence. How do safety engineers improve their job performance. Building interpersonal relationships in higher education. Explorations in getting one s way article pdf available in journal of applied psychology 654. A total of 117 employees of a manufacturing firm anonymously completed the multifactor leadership questionnaireform 5 bass, 1985a and the profile of organizational influence strategies.
647 231 229 1369 745 113 1306 112 1213 1437 261 735 191 732 980 466 145 1371 1404 6 671 1320 1144 302 1234 632 917 1239 834 242 1005 1352 565 997 1061 947 420 833 614 1100 1413 144 1228